Armenian Studies 10: One Student's
Experience
by Jacklin Gharibian
Armenians--they have such strange names and facial features, an aberrant language
(with peculiar-looking alphabets), and a distinctly odd culture. I always felt this
strangeness within myself, and I reckoned that we were, somehow, different from others.
However, I later learned that Armenians are, instead, distinctly unique. I also presumed
that I knew enough about these "strangers"--about the Genocide, Tigran the Great, William
Saroyan, and the Armenians of California. How can one not know anything about their
culture and history? But, I discovered that my knowledge was very limited and inadequate-
-there is always something more, among the masses, that comes across your face as a non-
coincidental surprise. Then you hear yourself say: "Wow, is it really true that Armenians
did that? I had no idea!"
I registered for Armenian Studies 10 (Introduction to Armenian Studies) for the
1995 fall semester with Dr. Dickran Kouymjian, carrying all of my pre-conceived opinions
and convictions about Armenians. Within the first hour of the class session, I knew that
the class would offer "something" more than just the lecture hours, exams, and reports.
Instead, I sensed that I would encounter challenges that would ultimately reshape my
thinking habits.
For the first seven weeks of the semester, we studied a book written by Michael J.
Arlen called Passage to Ararat. This book was primarily about Arlen's journey to Armenia
which led him to discover his roots and allowed him to come in terms with his father, his
Armenianess, and himself. Arlen, who at times claimed he, "Hated being an Armenian,"
covered nearly all subject matters that Armenians have experienced from the birth of their
nationhood. For instance, the author wrote about the Kings of Nairi, the Kingdom of
Urartu, Tigran the Great, the Armenian community of Fresno, Armenian rug merchants,
Armenian architecture, the Dashnaks, and most important of all, the 1915 Genocide. These
matters concern Armenians, yet Arlen crafted his novel in a manner that grasped the
attention of non-Armenians as well. He brought out universal questions in life, showing
that Armenians have the same needs as other human beings.
Why did the 1915 Genocide take place, and why is it that Armenians, after 80
years, have not yet healed their souls? Coming into the class, I knew the answer for the
first question, but I had difficulties with the second. Several films were shown in class to
help clarify the misunderstandings or our misconceptions about the massacres, such as An
Armenian Journey, The Hidden Holocaust, Everyone's Not Here: Families of the
Armenian Genocide, and The Armenian Case. In the Armenian Studies 10, Syllabus
Reader, we further examined the details of the Genocide. All of this, along with Dr.
Kouymjian's lectures, served the key to my understanding of, "The crime of the century."
I knew that the Turkish government completely denied the Genocide ever taking place in
history, but I further learned that they alleged that the Armenians were revolting against the
Ottoman Empire and that they were the ones who massacred the Turks. Their proof for
this misguided assertion were the guns that were collected from the Armenians and the
Turks who were killed during W.W.I. Perhaps, those who survived the Genocide can not
"forget and forgive" because of the guilt they sense for being fortunate enough to have
escaped death, or because of the anger they feel for not being recognized as the victims of a
calculated crime and instead being portrayed as the aggressors.
We, then, went on to study about the Armenian Apostolic church. We began with
the administrative structure or the hierarchy of the Apostolic church. From here on, it
seemed as if the church was indirectly regulated through politics. For instance, from
1441-1956, Armenians were served by a Catholicos in Etchmiadzin and a second one in
Sis/Antelias; this created a division in the church. Also, Armenia was overtaken by Russia
in 1921, and this caused another problem, because Communists were against religion;
thus, all of the monasteries were closed and the Catholics in Armenia turned to Antelias for
help. Armenians were then caught in the trap of Communism and the Cold War. The
effects of this reached the heart of Fresno and a clear division was apparent between Holy
Trinity Armenian Apostolic Church and St. Paul Armenian Apostolic Church. (Of course,
the details are too lengthy to explain.)
Beyond this, we had to visit two Armenian churches, one Apostolic and one
Protestant; then, we were to write a report on the differences that exist between them.
Therefore, I visited Holy Trinity and Pilgrim Congregational. I am a member of an
Apostolic Armenian Church, and I never had the opportunity to visit any of the Protestant
Churches. This was a phenomenal experience, for I was startled to recognize the
uniqueness of each church. Although I belong to the Apostolic Church, I must confess that
I do not completely comprehend all the traditions of my religion. Many young Armenians
face this conflict; I blame this situation on myself and not on my parents, the Church, or its
structure. Intellectually, to understand the traditions of worshipping God in the Apostolic
Church, one has to recognize the symbolism of the Batarak.. On the other hand, one can
just step into the Protestant Church and know exactly what is occurring. The Armenian
Protestant Church is "Americanized." It's user-friendly--the services are to the point,
direct, and understandable, and it's modernized to fulfill the needs of the people and to help
them confront the issues and predicaments of modern society. The Apostolic Church,
however, aims to preserve cultural traditions, in particular, the Armenian language and
history. In a sense, we are cautioned to always look back (to examine where we came
from) before taking any steps forward. Personally, I enjoyed the services of the Protestant
church, because it was intellectually direct. However, I attend church to be spiritually
shaken, not intellectually. Therefore, the Apostolic church resolves the situation, even if I
do not totally comprehend all of what it has to offer.
Next, we studied one of the most magnificent (American) writers of the 20th
century-William Saroyan. I never studied William Saroyan's writings, while attending
school in the Fresno Unified School District (other than just reading one of his short plays
in my Ethnic Studies class). However, I managed to read some of his works on a "part-
time" basis. Most of the students in the class had not read the works of Saroyan. How
could a person grow up in the Valley and not know Saroyan? I do not understand why
administrators or individual instructors make certain that their students learn something
about a local citizen who later became a world renowned writer? In class, we studied a
short story called The Armenian Mouse, another one called The Daring Young Man on the
Flying Trapeze, and finally we read two of the three Saroyan plays that were edited (in An
Armenian Trilogy) by Dr. Kouymjian, Armenians and Bitlis. Saroyan proudly admitted he
was an Armenian, and believing in the human spirit, he acknowledged Armenians are part
of the human race. In other words, Armenians should be classified as a minority group
that is an alliance of the majority, and not exclusive of it.
Finally, we ended the class with two subjects, the Armenian militant movement and
the Armenian community of Fresno. From 1975 to 1983, young Armenians developed
terrorist ideas towards Turkish government officials to gain the attention of the world about
the Genocide. For 60 years, the peaceful marches and demonstrations never grabbed the
mindfulness of the media; the aim of the two terrorist organizations, the Armenian Secret
Army for the Liberation of Armenia and the Justice Commandos for the Armenian
Genocide, was to resolve this situation. The media breathes to cover accounts that involve
drama and action, and no one realistically cared to hear about 1.5 million people who were
massacred in the Ottoman Empire infinite decades ago. The young radicals, having realized
this point, began to kill Turkish ambassadors, set bombs, high-jack planes and carry out
other revolutionary actions. By the end of the movement, the world heard about the
Genocide and Turkey was compelled to give an explanation of history. However, Turkey
not only continued to deny the Genocide, but it proclaimed that there was a civil war and
the Armenians were the ones who massacred the Turks. It is ironic to realize how violence
called upon violence and that it was thought to be the only way to solve the "Armenian
Question" for the Turks and the question of the Genocide for the Armenians. One side
attempted, viciously, to end human life in its masses, while the fragmented side struggled
out of desperation to reveal the savagery and inhumanity of it all.
At last, we ended the course with the Armenian community of Fresno and the
history of its settlement in the Valley. To help us understand the background of the
community, we viewed a documentary called, Strangers in a Promised Land. This film,
which was narrated by former Governor George Deukmajian, illustrated how the
community grew from the late 1890's to the early 1980's. In the beginning, Armenians
were treated as second-class citizens and were considered to be inferior, but with their hard
work and hard-earned fortunes many became leading citizens of the Valley. Today, there
exists diversity within the Armenian community of Fresno with Armenians continuing to
immigrate to the region from counties of the Middle East, Russia, the Republic of Armenia,
and Mediterranean countries. Personally, I consider Fresno to be a model community for
the Armenians in the Diaspora.
Yes, this is what I learned, but it's only about one fifth of what was covered in the
lectures. I thought I knew enough about my culture? What a funny joke. I now realize
that I need to learn more about my culture and the human culture to become a better citizen
of both cultures. Armenian Studies 10, introduction to Armenian Studies was more of an
introduction to understanding the human self in its deepest uncensored and universal form.
There is nothing strange, aberrant, peculiar, or odd about Armenians. We are not
strangers. We are just six or seven million people roaming about the globe, trying to
preserve our "i-a-n's" and "y-a-n's".